Custom Orthotics vs. Drugstore Insoles: What Parents Need to Know

As parents, you’ll do anything to keep your child comfortable, active, and pain-free. When it comes to foot health, one common question is whether to choose custom orthotics or drugstore insoles.
While both options can improve comfort, they serve very different purposes  and understanding those differences ensures your child gets the right care from the start.

Understanding Pediatric Orthotics

At Pediatric Foot & Ankle, orthotics are often the first line of treatment for resolving pediatric foot pain and gait concerns.
These custom-made devices are designed specifically for your child’s feet correcting the cause of discomfort, not just cushioning it.

Common conditions that benefit from custom pediatric orthotics include:

Custom orthotics for Sever’s Disease have up to a 95% success rate within 4–6 weeks — often covered by insurance.

Condition-Specific Orthotic Solutions

Unlike drugstore inserts, custom orthotics are prescribed and molded to address a diagnosed problem, not a general ache.
Each device is made to control motion, correct alignment, and provide long-term comfort especially important for growing children who play sports or spend hours on their feet.

The Custom Orthotics Casting Process

At Pediatric Foot & Ankle, we use the STS Sock Casting Method an advanced, distortion-free molding system that captures your child’s exact foot shape.
This precision ensures:

  • A perfect, comfortable fit

  • No slow break-in period

  • Immediate, lasting relief

The accuracy of this method helps your child feel results faster and supports long-term correction.

Are Prescription Orthotics Really Superior?

Yes. While drugstore insoles like Dr. Scholl’s or PowerStep may provide temporary relief, they can’t match the tailored support of prescription orthotics.
Drugstore insoles are mass-produced and not designed to correct pediatric conditions such as Sever’s Disease or flat feet.

They’re a short-term option if your insurance doesn’t cover orthotics but not a substitute for proper treatment.
Always consult a pediatric podiatrist to determine the best solution based on your child’s diagnosis, activity level, and budget.

Pediatric vs. Adult Orthotics

Children’s feet are not just smaller versions of adult feet they grow, move, and function differently.
Pediatric orthotics are made with flexibility and growth in mind, usually three-quarter length to fit into sports shoes and sneakers.

They also feature a deeper heel cup to stabilize growth plates something many general labs can’t accommodate.
This is why choosing a provider like Pediatric Foot & Ankle is essential for proper long-term results.

The Role of Anti-Inflammatories

To make the transition into orthotics easier, our specialists may recommend a short course of anti-inflammatories.
This helps reduce swelling and ensures your child adapts comfortably to their new orthotics.

Why Choose Pediatric Foot & Ankle

At Pediatric Foot & Ankle, our board-certified specialists including Dr. Mikkel Jarman  focus exclusively on children’s foot and ankle care.
We provide comprehensive treatment plans that include:

  • Custom orthotics and braces

  • Condition-specific rehabilitation

  • Sports injury management

  • Long-term growth monitoring

Our goal: help your child move pain-free and confidently at every stage of development.

Schedule an Appointment

If your child is experiencing foot or heel pain, don’t settle for over-the-counter fixes.
Custom pediatric orthotics provide the support, alignment, and relief your child needs to stay active and healthy.

 

Schedule your visit with Dr. Jarman at Pediatric Foot & Ankle to explore personalized solutions for your child’s comfort and long-term mobility.

Share this post

All content on PediatricFootAnkle.com is written by or collaborated with Dr. Mikkel Jarman to be accurate and informative and helpful to the reader.

Close-up of a child walking on tiptoes indoors, illustrating pediatric toe walking condition, used by Pediatric Foot & Ankle

Pediatric Toe Walking: Causes, Treatments, and When to Act

https://pediatricfootankle.com/wp-content/uploads/toe-walking-video.mp4 When a child walks on the balls of their feet instead of their heels, it’s called pediatric toe walking. While common in toddlers, persistent toe walking can lead to long-term gait issues and joint

Read More »

Your Child's Feet Are Designed For Life

image showing the new office location we're opening in Gilbert AZ